Compare this to the .357 Critical Duty, which penetrated to about 18.9 inches, had identical expansion, and approximately 100 feet more of muzzle velocity. I’m not sure where you got your info, but when you said “The 10mm was their second hope followed by the .40.” I took it you implied that the .357 SIG came before the 10mm? What that all those numbers mean in layman’s terms is that all you get with .357 Sig is a round that costs more money, for no improvement in terminal ballistics. ? I have a friend who keeps a .357 Sig Glock for just this reason. Striker-Fired Compact Pistol . What’s the barrel length on your S&W Shield? Critical Duty 9mm vs. 357 Sig Comparison. I always looked at it as a slightly watered down .357 mag. I’m another one that sides with the .357Sig. Even the extremely hot 9mm +P+ with the same bullet weight runs about 150 feet per second slower than just the standard .357 SIG load. SIG partnered up with another big name in the firearms world to make this happen: Federal Cartridge, now called Federal Premium Ammunition. Aber dafür hab ich mir ne … Budget always controls preferences in the field. 6 rounds of .357 mag or 16 of .357 sig? It’ll only be a matter of whether the owner would be okay with reaming the barrel’s chamber to accept 9×23 Winchester or just sticking with .38 Super. I’ve spoken with many Ex LEO and a few Ex FBI agents at gun shows and every one of them said the same thing the only reason the 9mm was chosen by the FBI and LEO was not because the 9mm was a better because they even said it wasn’t, it was because there agents and officers were only hitting their targets less than 30 percent or less of the time (look up the report) which they the LEO and agents blamed on recoil of 40SW and 357Sig and with the 9mm you got less recoil for faster follow up shots and 2+ extra rounds yet know the standard FBI and LEO 9mm round is now a +p or a +p+ round which know that so called recoil that they blamed on the 40sw and 357sig is worse with the 9MM then it was with the 40SW and 357SIG. It’s just too easy. If I were in need of shooting thru my door while inside my vehicle I trust it would be more effective than a 9mm. Despite less use than other cartridges, the .357 SIG is a fast, accurate, and powerful cartridge that can be used for target shooting, personal defense, and even hunting..357 SIG Quick Facts: The idea of having a gun the size, recoil and capacity close to 9mm with the stopping power of .357 Magnum was a very good idea. I own a S&W shield in .40. You need a oal of 1.2 in for those to be at there peak power. Thanks, glad you liked the article. To start we need to look at the history of each cartridge. Although, if you recall from an earlier piece about Major and Minor Power Factor in USPSA, one thing you can do with a .357 Sig is make Major Power Factor easily with factory loaded ammo. IIRC the .357 SIG was designed to be fired from barrels around 4 inches in length or longer — though it’s still faster than any 9mm load I know when fired from a 3-inch, I really don’t see the point. So please do not take this article too seriously. Comments on the .357 SIG . Customary Metric . No question, the caliber wars will continue as long as firearms are being used. I would recommend getting a Glock 23 and getting a .357 SIG conversion or better yet, get a Glock 32 and don’t bother converting it to .40 S&W. photography by R.K. Campbell. 357 Sig is a great cartridge, but even with higher velocities and muzzle energy, it’s still a handgun and it doesn’t stop bad guys any better than the .40, 9mm or 45 ACP. With the 9mm HST, all five rounds met or exceeded the FBI’s penetration guidelines of 12-18 inches. Striker-Fired Subcompact Pistol *Buying ammo from LuckyGunner.com helps support HandgunHero. Which caliber will make it through the most boards? this leaves guns like the 10mm glock 20’s, they are bigger, breach face is still 40/357/10mm brass sized, too large for extraction 100% of the time, mag lips are an issue. But there are small bores and then there is the .38 Super and the .357 Magnum. Because it didn’t really catch on as far as popularity, partly due to it being released just a few years after the .40 S&W and partly due to it not really having any practical advantages over other more established handgun calibers, ammo availability tends to be an issue in some states. They advertise 1475fps, for 357sig but it chronos at 1500+ untill you put it in a Glock 33 then it comes in at advertised or slightly under. I think carrying typical 125-grain .357 SIG loads is pushing it — I can be wrong as I’ve never had to shoot a bear before, but in such scenarios it’s better to err on the safe side. Since then, I’ve acquired a P239(for carry) and a P229(for my wife.) The high-pressure rating of the brass can also push the typical 115-grain .355 caliber projectile out of a 4.65-inch barrel with muzzle velocities of up to 1,180 feet per second. Cheers! So what are your thoughts between these? Your email address will not be published. Let’s take a look at terminal ballistics. Coy Getman As Sylvester Stallone so eloquently put it in Rocky VI, “The world ain’t all sunshine and rainbows!” This is the sad truth, and doubly more so in the case of the .357 SIG. Not sure if you’re still monitoring this discussion any longer but regardless, I think this is a good comparison article except for one point. LOL! Most agencies in our areas had the Glock 22 / .40 so we were told to accept the .45+p by R.K. Campbell. That said I carry 9mm and .357 sig off duty. 20€ pro pak.). It can send a same-size, same-weight bullet flying at much faster velocities which results to better terminal ballistics. It is a very accurate round and it is very good for self defense the question is can you afford to shoot it. Here are some other reasons why I think the round has yet to win the popularity contest: If life is as easy as doing ballistics comparisons, then it would be a no-brainer to state that the .357 SIG trumps the 9mm. 2. But since it’s easier to buy new cartridges than teach people to shoot better, we got the 10mm, then the .40 S&W, then .357 Sig. This meant that most popular and cheapest of rounds was unavailable not only at your local gun shops and big box stores, but even online. I have both….carry both at times because for me I interpreted the creation of the .357Sig for a specialized reason. While the bullet diameter is the same as the wonder nine, most.357 Sig projectiles are shaped differently. It is nonsensical to say that 9mm is “much better” than 380 and then make the argument that 9mm is “just as good” as 357 Sig or Mag. Georg Luger, an Austrian sharpeye, patented a design for a pistol he so aptly named after himself in 1898, the Luger P08. Joined: Dec 29, 2006 Messages: 10,684 Location: Alabama. I purchased a G31 to replace the 357 Mag I used as a truck/woods gun and would point out that my 357 Sig plinking loaf is 1350 FPS while my self defense loads hits 1380 FPS. The 9mm (124 +P & standard 147 grain,) 357 Sig and 40S&W are too close to offer any real advantage in self defense. https://gunnewsdaily.com/fk-brno-field-pistol-review/. The problem is the .357 SIG also has a reputation for being hard to reload, so while a few are able to successfully reload. Only time will tell if it would gain the kind of resurgence in popularity the 10mm is enjoying now — both of us can only hope. The velocity of the .357 SIG 125-grain JHP bullet doesn't appear to make it superior in penetrating automotive sheet metal, windshield glass or other hard barrier materials than existing 9mm, .40 S&W and .45 ACP JHP bullets. For all other purposes the 9mm wins due to comfort and ease of carry. I’m not dismissing the .357 SIG. This effectively duplicates factory .357 magnum loads fired from a 4-inch revolver barrel. Shoot Straight! Not sure why the .357 Sig is being evaluated as a hunting cartridge? The.357 Sig uses a.355 inch diameter bullet like the 9mm, not a.357 diameter bullet like the.357 Magnum and.38 Special. They also have no idea what someone has been shot with just by looking at them. That being said, I personally choose 357 Sig over 40S&W because it shoots flatter which means more accuracy for me. I can only hope its popularity catches on in the not so distant future — it deserves more. The .357 Mag’s origins begin in the early 1930’s where the police force was in desperate need of a better terminal performing handgun load. @JD Donham LMAO! That transition was suspended after recruits in the A-2014 class, the first to train with the new S&W M&P 9mm polymer handguns, experienced numerous malfunctions with those weapons. And thank you for taking the time to read through it all, Joe. But let’s get back to the question of .357 Sig vs. 9mm, and ask ourselves this. Lässt sich gut händeln und ist sehr führig. I’m one of those guys that carriers a different gun and caliber every week just for fun, but if I’m going to a bad part of town or on a trip, it’s the 357 SIG for all the reasons ThePersonalProtectionSpecialist mentioned. Hi, I am just an average guy with a CHL. There have been many times I asked myself this question: If I survived a holocaust of some sort — like say a zombie apocalypse or a nuclear fallout — and there was only one semi-auto handgun caliber left in the world, what would that be for me? Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; Smith & Wesson . As far as the barrier/glass penetration bit and all other things you mentioned, I can’t agree more. Your comment made my day. Together, they … In a perfect world where money is never going to be an issue, I’d tell anyone who asks for a recommendation to buy any handgun chambered for this round if only to give it the chance it deserves. There is still plenty of .357 Sig out there. Thays just fine with me. However, there is one HUGE advantage to .357 Sig over 9mm. In this article I will be comparing two kinds of similar but very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the .357 SIG. Then there’s its sister and mother cartridges the .40 S&W and 10mm respectively, the magazines for which will fit the same number of rounds — the .40 being one of the three most common handgun calibers in the world (which the .357 SIG really should have rendered obsolete were it destined for greatness), there’s just no hope for the .357 SIG as far as popularity in the foreseeable future. My only real concern with Sig 357 is overpenetration. Its tapered brass that can withstand a SAAMI pressure limit of 35,000 psi (241 MPa) is quite tiny and allows for typical single-stack magazines designed for its arguably biggest rival, the .45 acp, to hold up to 22% more ammo. As a result, shooters have stripped bare gun stores and online retailers of 9mm ammo. The Broad Side Everyone says the .357 sig is a 9mm on steroids. If it’s good enough to guard the President, it’s good enough for me. IdaD, Jun 13, 2019 #5. Of course, on the plus side the 9mm is a very utilitarian cartridge available world-wide and with proper defensive ammo it is a good stopper. They looked at the 10mm and accepted a bullet redesigned as the .40 S&W. Thumbnail: shootout with a Meth Head blasting us, he was hit 9 times within 12-15 feet, both lungs punched out, one hit through the neck severing his carotid artery and he ran like a zombie in WW 3 MOVIE. Bullets of the same weight will approximate the same velocities in SIG and +P+. So, is more muzzle velocity better or is it not? jacketed hollow points (JHPs) and jacketed soft points (JSPs) both can be great man-stoppers. To use the logic that 9mm is as good as the .357 Sig is the same as saying the .38 Special is as good as the .357 Magnum. We chronied our guns (mine was SIG P229, 3.9″ Bbl 125gr at 1365 FPS) then took turns at shooting a ballistic dummy wearing body armor. The 125gr HST in .357 Sig also met the FBI’s penetration guidelines. Therefore, you could make a use case for it as a crisis-stockpiling resistant caliber. Handguns have always been for the immediate threat to end a confrontation with a bad guy. But if your Shield is a 4-inch then it might be worth trying.
Chest Supported Dumbbell Row Alternative, Bernat Premium Yarn Uk, Fake Phone Number For Verification Philippines, Foreshadowing Example Despicable Me, Susie Cakes Chocolate Cake Recipe, Bundy Selmer Clarinet Serial Number Lookup, Examples Of Non Nursing Theories, Notes Activity In Epic, How To Reduce High Magnesium Levels In Soil, Bend Will Shout Location,